Mon to Fri, 10am to 6pm (628) 281-5885
Menu
  1. Home
  2. Coin Notes
  3. Spotting counterfeits

Counterfeit coins and how to spot them

The most common fakes are copies of Morgan dollars, Trade dollars, gold coins and California fractional gold. Wrong weight, wrong size, soft or mushy details and odd color are the usual giveaways. Proper testing of weight, dimensions and metal is the only reliable check.

Magnifying glass over a red tray of gold and silver coins, including an American Silver Eagle

The fakes that turn up most

Counterfeits come in waves, and some types turn up again and again.

  • Morgan and Trade dollars made of base metal
  • Gold coins, especially small dollars and quarter eagles
  • California fractional gold and bear tokens
  • Altered dates, like a 1944-D cent tooled to look like 1914-D
  • Added mint marks on common coins
  • Fake grading holders

Simple warning signs

A coin that weighs too little or too much, measures wrong, looks greasy or soft, rings dull when tapped or has a strange color deserves suspicion. Silver dollars that stick to a magnet are fake. None of these tests is proof on its own.

How proper testing works

We weigh every questionable coin on a precise scale, measure its diameter and thickness, compare the details with known genuine examples under magnification and test the metal without harming the coin. If a coin fails, we explain what we found and give it back.

Fake grading holders

Counterfeit PCGS and NGC holders exist. We check the holder's construction and look up the certification number in the grading company's database. A real number with the wrong coin inside is a red flag.

Quick answers

Can I test silver with a magnet?

Silver is not magnetic, so a coin that sticks is fake. A coin that does not stick still needs testing.

Will you buy a coin you think is fake?

No. We explain what we found and return it.

Ready to sell? See free coin appraisals with San Francisco Coin Buyers.

Find out what your coins are worth

Call for a free private appraisal anywhere in San Francisco, the East Bay or the Peninsula. Every coin is graded and weighed where you can watch, and the offer is written down.

Call (628) 281-5885 Request a written offer online Monday to Friday, 10am to 6pm. No obligation to sell.
Call (628) 281-5885