Skip to main content
Free coin and gold appraisals by appointment across San Francisco and the Bay Area (628) 281-5885
San Francisco Coin BuyersCoins · Gold · Silver
Menu

Selling old coins in San Francisco

Albums, rolls, jars and bags of dollars. We pull out the silver, check every S mint coin for the scarce dates and tell you plainly what is common.

Album of old U.S. coins with a loupe

Coins from San Francisco homes

San Francisco had its own mint, so local banks and stores handled freshly struck S mint coins for generations. Families in the Excelsior, the Mission and the Avenues pulled them from change, kept rolls straight from the bank and filled folders that are still in closets today.

Most of what we see is common. But because the coins came from right here, Bay Area collections hold more scarce S mint dates than collections in most cities, and we check every one.

Sorting a San Francisco coin jar

Pour out a coin jar from a San Francisco house and you usually find the same layers. Copper cents from the 1950s on, a scattering of nickels, some silver dimes and quarters that someone pulled from change in the 1960s, a few Franklin or Kennedy halves and, more often than in other cities, a handful of S mint wheat cents.

We split the pile by metal first, then go through the silver and the older copper for dates worth more than melt. Only then does the silver go on the scale.

Barber and Seated Liberty silver

Older Bay Area families sometimes hold silver coins from the 1800s: Seated Liberty dimes, quarters and halves from before 1891 and Barber coins from 1892 to 1916. San Francisco struck large numbers of both. Many are worn smooth, but even worn examples of some dates carry premiums, and coins with sharp detail can be worth many times their silver.

Uncirculated rolls

Because the mint was right here, some local families got rolls of brand-new coins straight from the bank and never opened them. Original rolls of S mint cents, nickels and dimes from the 1940s and 1950s still turn up. Leave them closed until the appointment. We open them with you and check every coin.

What happens if you keep some

Lots of sellers keep a birth year coin or a set a parent built. The written offer lists every coin or group separately, so you pick what to sell. Holding back a few pieces does not change the price on the rest.

Coins found during a remodel

Old San Francisco houses give up surprises when walls come down: coins under floorboards, a tin behind a chimney, a few gold pieces in a wall cavity. Bring them exactly as you found them, dirt and all. Cleaning can ruin collector value that a careful look might find.

Trade dollars and the China trade

The trade dollar was struck from 1873 to 1885 for commerce in Asia, and San Francisco made millions of them. Many were shipped to China, where merchants stamped them with small characters called chopmarks to show they had tested the silver. Chopmarked trade dollars are a collecting specialty of their own. Plain trade dollars are 90 percent silver and carry collector premiums, and fakes are common, so each one is tested.

Coins we buy

  • Indian Head and wheat cents, including S mint dates
  • Buffalo nickels and silver war nickels
  • Barber, Mercury and Roosevelt silver dimes
  • Barber, Standing Liberty and Washington silver quarters
  • Walking Liberty, Franklin and Kennedy halves
  • Morgan, Peace and trade dollars
  • Uncirculated rolls and S mint proof sets
  • PCGS and NGC graded coins

How old coins are priced

Silver dimes, quarters, halves and dollars from before 1965 always carry at least their silver value. Copper and nickel coins start at face value and rise only for scarce dates or strong condition.

Above that floor, mint and condition decide the price. Many S mint coins were struck in smaller numbers than their Philadelphia twins, so we look at every one closely and price the better ones individually.

Further reading: S mint coins worth money

Ask for a free offer

We call back the same day to book a private time.

Or call (628) 281-5885

Also buying

Common questions

Is my 1909-S penny worth money?
A 1909-S VDB is scarce and worth a good deal. A plain 1909-S without the VDB initials is also scarce. We check both.
Do you buy uncirculated rolls?
Yes. Leave the rolls closed until the appointment and we will open and check them with you.
Should I clean my coins?
No. Cleaning lowers the value. Bring them as they are.